Spotify
Stream Now, Artists Get Paid Never
$73B
Value Extracted
8
Key Initiatives
Spotify is the streaming platform that extracts from both listeners and artists. In April 2024 it stopped paying royalties on any track under 1,000 annual streams, and in February 2026 it raised US Premium to $12.99 — its third hike since 2023. EnshitifAi assigns Spotify an Extraction Index of $73B.
The Story
Spotify disrupted the music industry by making music nearly free for consumers. We helped them realize the next step: make it nearly free for artists too, while charging labels for 'Discovery Mode' placement. The platform extracts from both sides now.
Common Questions
Is Spotify enshittified?
Yes. In April 2024 Spotify stopped paying any royalty on tracks with fewer than 1,000 streams in the prior 12 months — a change the United Musicians and Allied Workers union estimated could affect roughly 86% of catalog tracks — while reallocating about $40 million toward larger rightsholders. Meanwhile it raised US Premium three times in three years, reaching $12.99/month in February 2026. By EnshitifAi's reckoning it is a textbook two-sided squeeze.
What dark patterns does Spotify use?
Discovery Mode, launched in 2020, lets artists trade a 30% royalty cut for algorithmic promotion in Radio, Autoplay, and Mixes — a practice the Recording Academy and Future of Music Coalition liken to payola, and which a 2025 class-action lawsuit challenged as undisclosed pay-to-play. Spotify also shrank Release Radar, locked down third-party APIs, and pushed a TikTok-style feed UI users never requested.
When did Spotify start enshittifying artist pay?
The pivotal shift was April 2024, when Spotify's new monetization policy excluded sub-1,000-stream tracks from the royalty pool entirely, ending the prior rule where any 30-second play earned money. Per-stream payouts have stayed around fractions of a cent even as Premium prices climbed to $12.99 in 2026. EnshitifAi treats 2024 as the formal demonetization milestone in its index.
How much has Spotify Premium gone up?
US individual Premium rose from $9.99 to $10.99 in July 2023, to $11.99 in June 2024, and to $12.99 effective February 2026 — three increases in three years — with Duo reaching $18.99 and Family $21.99. EnshitifAi notes artist per-stream payouts did not rise alongside these hikes; the index reflects that one-sided escalation as opinion, not a company-reported figure.
Key Achievements
- 1
Demonetized 67% of tracks by introducing minimum stream thresholds
- 2
Launched 'Discovery Mode' where artists take 30% pay cuts for visibility (legal payola)
- 3
Shrunk Release Radar from 200 tracks to 30 while adding major label spam
- 4
Let AI-generated music flood the platform to dilute royalty pools
- 5
Removed features users loved, added features nobody asked for (TikTok clone UI)
- 6
Locked down APIs, breaking third-party apps and tools
- 7
CEO invested hundreds of millions in military drone company while paying artists $0.003/stream
- 8
Hiked US Premium pricing in Q1 2026 to $12.99+/month — the third hike in three years — while artist per-stream payouts remained flat and the Discovery Mode 30%-cut lane continued to widen as the de facto default
We disrupted music by making everyone equally unhappy—except shareholders.
D. Ek
Chief Disruption Officer
Want Results Like These?
Schedule your complimentary Value Extraction Assessment today.